Calligraphy
Brush pens vs. dip pens vs. broad-edge pens: which calligraphy tool should a beginner choose?
We don't earn anything from these links yet.
If that changes, this note will say so on the same day. Prices and availability are set by Amazon and change often.
Every calligraphy tool solves one problem: how to make some lines thick and others thin. The way a tool solves it decides how it feels, what styles it suits, and how hard it is to learn. Once you understand that, the wall of pens in an art shop becomes much less confusing.
Three ways to make a thick line
- Flexible brush tip: press harder and the tip spreads, so the line widens.
- Flexible pointed nib: press on a downstroke and the two halves of a metal nib open, letting more ink through.
- Flat, broad edge: the nib is a fixed width. Pull it sideways along its edge for a thin line, or along its width for a thick one. Pressure barely matters.
Brush pens
A brush pen is a marker with a flexible tip, made either of felt-like fiber or of individual bristles. Fiber tips hold their shape well and are the usual choice for beginners. Bristle tips can produce lovely, textured strokes but need a lighter, more experienced hand.
Brush pens come in sizes. Small tips are easier to control and suit cards, journals, and envelopes. Large tips make dramatic letters but magnify every wobble, so they are better as a second pen.
Pros: no ink bottles, no cleaning, portable, and quick to start. Cons: tips wear out, especially on rough paper; many are not refillable; and thin hairlines take practice because you must lift almost all pressure on upstrokes.
Pointed dip pens
A pointed dip pen is a holder with a removable steel nib that you dip into ink. It is the tool behind copperplate and Spencerian scripts, and many professional wedding calligraphers use it. The hairlines can be extraordinarily fine and the swells very full.
Pros: the most elegant contrast of any tool; nibs are inexpensive and replaceable; any color of suitable ink. Cons: a steep start. The nib can catch on paper and spray ink, needs regular dipping and cleaning, and works best on smooth, good-quality paper. Many teachers suggest building pressure control with a brush pen before moving to a pointed nib.
Some setups also use an oblique holder, which angles the nib to help right-handers hold the steep slant of copperplate. That is a refinement for later, not a first purchase.
Broad-edge pens
A broad-edge pen has a flat, chisel-shaped nib. You hold it at a constant angle to the writing line (for many classic hands, somewhere between 30 and 45 degrees), and the shape of the stroke does the rest. Downstrokes come out wide, side strokes thin, and curves swell and taper on their own.
Broad-edge tools include dip nibs, fountain-pen style pens with flat nibs, and chisel-tip markers. Pens with a cartridge, such as the Pilot Parallel in our kit guide, are a tidy way to start: no dipping and no ink bottles.
Pros: pressure-free and steady; letters look “calligraphic” very early; ideal for italic, foundational, uncial, and blackletter styles. Cons: wider nibs need large letters; maintaining a constant angle takes discipline; and the look is more formal than modern brush script.
Side by side
| Brush pen | Pointed dip pen | Broad-edge pen | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Contrast from | Pressure | Pressure | Angle |
| Styles | Modern script | Copperplate, Spencerian, modern pointed pen | Italic, foundational, blackletter |
| Mess | None | Ink bottles, cleaning | Low with cartridges |
| Beginner friendliness | High | Low | Medium to high |
| Best paper | Smooth | Very smooth, good sizing | Smooth, low feathering |
How to choose
- You like flowing, bouncy, contemporary lettering: start with a small brush pen.
- You love classic manuscripts, certificates, or gothic letters: start with a broad-edge pen.
- You dream of formal wedding envelopes in copperplate: start with a brush pen to learn pressure, then move to a pointed dip pen after a month or two.
- You honestly don’t know: try a small brush pen and one broad-edge pen. After a couple of weeks of trying both, you will probably have a sense of which one your hand prefers.
Questions
Can I use a regular felt-tip marker?
You can practice letter shapes with any pen, adding thickness to downstrokes by drawing a second line beside them. This is sometimes called faux calligraphy and is a good way to learn structure. But it is slower than writing with a pressure-sensitive tool.
Are fountain pens calligraphy pens?
Only if the nib is shaped for it. A standard round fountain-pen nib writes a mostly even line. Flat (italic or stub) nibs and flexible nibs can add contrast.
Keep going
See the beginner calligraphy kit for the three tools we suggest starting with, or browse all calligraphy articles.