Colored pencils

How to choose colored pencils: wax vs. oil, student vs. artist grade

Updated November 20, 2026 · About 10 minutes to read

We don't earn anything from these links yet.

If that changes, this note will say so on the same day. Prices and availability are set by Amazon and change often.

The short answer

If you color mostly in books and want an easy start, a student-grade wax set is a sensible first step. If you already know you love colored pencil and want richer blends, move to an artist-grade set. Choose a soft wax core for creamy, painterly color, and an oil-based core for crisp detail and many thin layers. Buy fewer, better colors before you buy more colors.

Wax-based or oil-based

Every colored pencil core is pigment held together by a binder. Most pencils use wax; some artist lines use a larger share of oil. The difference shows up as soon as you start layering.

How the two families usually behave
Wax-basedOil-based
FeelSoft, creamy, glides easilyFirmer, drier, more controlled
PointWears down fasterHolds a sharp point longer
LayeringBuilds color quickly; the paper fills up soonerMany thin layers before the paper stops taking color
Wax bloomPossible on heavy layers (a hazy film you can wipe gently)Not usually an issue
Typical useBold color, smooth blends, burnishingFine detail, realism, gradual shading

Neither family is better. Many experienced colorists use both: oil-based pencils for the early, light layers and detail, and wax-based pencils for the final, saturated layers.

Student or artist grade

“Student” and “artist” are labels makers give their own lines, not a regulated standard. In practice, artist-grade pencils usually carry more pigment, offer open-stock refills of single colors, and come with published lightfastness information. Student-grade pencils usually cost less, have firmer cores, and are perfectly good for coloring books and practice.

A simple test of whether you need artist grade: if you find yourself pressing hard to get the color you want, or the paper turns shiny before the color is deep enough, a higher pigment load will help.

Lightfastness: does it matter for you?

Lightfastness is how well a color resists fading in light. If your pages live in a closed book, it matters very little. If you plan to frame finished work or give it as a gift to hang, it matters a great deal.

Look for one of two things on the box, the listing, or the maker’s website: a rating for each color (some makers use stars or a numbered scale based on the Blue Wool Scale), or a statement that the line meets ASTM D6901, the U.S. standard specification for artists’ colored pencils. If you cannot find either, assume the colors are not rated.

How many colors you need

Fewer than you might think. Because colored pencil is layered, two or three pencils can make a color no single pencil contains. A good 24-color set covers most coloring books. Larger sets save time when a page has many small areas, and they are useful if you dislike mixing. They are not a sign of quality on their own.

Four sets compared

These four cover the main choices: a student wax set, an artist wax set, an artist oil set, and a large set aimed at adult colorists. They are listed from firmest to softest in feel, not ranked.

We don't earn anything from these links yet.

If that changes, this note will say so on the same day. Prices and availability are set by Amazon and change often.

Prismacolor Scholar, 24 colors

Listing title: Prismacolor Scholar Colored Pencils, Assorted, 24 Count · ASIN B000J07P9U

A student-grade, wax-based set from the same maker as Prismacolor Premier. The cores are firmer than Premier’s, which makes them less buttery but easier to keep sharp. The listing describes the set as made for beginner artists.

Good for
Trying colored pencils seriously for the first time; detailed coloring books where a fine point matters more than heavy blending.
Skip if
You already know you want soft, heavily blendable color or published lightfastness ratings.

See the current price on Amazon

Prismacolor Premier Soft Core, 24 colors

Listing title: Prismacolor Premier Colored Pencils, Soft Core, Assorted Colors, 24 Count · ASIN B00006IEEU

An artist-grade, wax-based pencil known for a very soft, creamy core. The listing describes it as made for blending, shading, and layering. Soft cores lay down a lot of color with little pressure but wear down faster and can snap if dropped.

Good for
Rich, saturated color and smooth blends; adults who color large areas and like a painterly finish.
Skip if
You press hard, sharpen to needle points for fine detail, or dislike wax bloom (a hazy film that can appear on heavy wax layers).

See the current price on Amazon

Faber-Castell Polychromos, tin of 24

Listing title: Faber-Castell Polychromos Artists' Color Pencils - Tin of 24 Colors - Premium Quality Artist Pencils · ASIN B0007OECK8

An oil-based, artist-grade pencil. The listing describes break-resistant leads (SV bonding) that are water-resistant and smudge-proof, and Faber-Castell’s own product page gives the lead as 3.8 mm thick. Faber-Castell publishes a lightfastness rating for Polychromos colors. Oil-based cores feel firmer than soft wax cores and hold a point well.

Good for
Many thin layers, crisp detail, and work you want to frame or keep; anyone bothered by wax bloom.
Skip if
Your priority is a large color range for the money. This is a premium set, and 24 colors is a starting palette.

See the current price on Amazon

Castle Art Supplies, 72 colors

Listing title: Castle Art Supplies 72 Colored Pencils for Adults - Soft Core Leads · ASIN B06ZZNF7GS

A large set marketed specifically to adult colorists, with soft cores according to the listing. It gives you a wide range of hues at once, which is convenient for detailed coloring books with many small areas.

Good for
Adults who want many colors right away for coloring books, before committing to an artist-grade brand.
Skip if
Longevity matters to you. We did not find per-color lightfastness ratings in the listing, so check before buying if your work will be displayed in daylight.

See the current price on Amazon

What else you will need

A sharpener that does not chew soft cores, a precise eraser, and paper that can take several layers make more difference than a bigger set. We cover all three in our guide to layering, blending, and burnishing.

Questions

Can I mix brands?

Yes. Pencils of different brands and binders can be layered on the same page. A common approach is firmer pencils first and softer ones last.

Why do my pencils keep breaking when I sharpen them?

Often the core was cracked inside the wood before you sharpened it, usually from being dropped. Soft cores are more fragile. A sharp blade and gentle, steady turns help, and so does storing pencils flat.

Are colored pencils and watercolor pencils the same?

No. Watercolor pencils have a water-soluble binder and are designed to be wetted with a brush. This guide covers dry colored pencils.