Our method
How we choose what we recommend
We don't earn anything from these links yet.
If that changes, this note will say so on the same day. Prices and availability are set by Amazon and change often.
A recommendation is only useful if you know how it was made. This page explains ours, including the limits of what we know.
Researched or tested: we tell you which
Every guide opens with a short note called “How we researched this.” If we have not used a product ourselves, we say so. In that case we rely on the manufacturer’s published specifications, the product listing, and well-documented properties of the material (for example, how wax-based pencils behave compared with oil-based ones). When we do test something hands-on, we will say exactly what we did, for how long, and on which paper, and we will use our own photos.
At the time of writing, the products in our first guides are researched, not hands-on tested.
What we weigh
- Core and binder. Wax-based or oil-based, soft or firm. This decides how a pencil layers and blends more than any other factor.
- Grade. Student-grade and artist-grade pencils differ in pigment load and, usually, in published lightfastness information.
- Lightfastness information. Whether the maker publishes ratings per color, and under which standard.
- Durability. Whether the maker describes a bonded or break-resistant core, and how easy the pencil is to sharpen.
- Range and fit. Whether the set covers what you will actually use, and whether open-stock refills exist.
- Relative cost. We describe sets as budget, mid-range, or premium. We never print a price.
Why there are no prices, stars, or review counts
Prices and availability on Amazon change often, sometimes several times a day, and depend on the seller and on where you are. A price printed on this site would soon be wrong. We also do not copy star ratings or customer reviews. Each product has a button that opens its current listing, where you can see the live price and the reviews for yourself.
How we make money
We don't earn anything from these links yet. Our product buttons are ordinary links to Amazon. If we join an affiliate program in the future, we may earn a commission when you buy through those links. If that happens, we will update every disclosure on this site the same day, and we will mark each paid link next to the link itself.
No brand has paid us, sent us free products, or reviewed our text before publication. If that ever changes for a specific product, we will say so next to that product.
What we will not do
- Claim we tested something we did not test.
- Rank products as “the best” without saying for whom and why.
- Invent urgency, such as “only a few left,” or mention a sale after it has ended.
- Make health claims. Many adults find coloring relaxing, and that is as far as we go.
Corrections
If we get a fact wrong, we fix it and note the change at the bottom of the guide with the date.